This article explores Transcendental Meditation (TM), a widely practiced form of meditation recognized for its profound psychological and physiological effects. Beginning with an overview of its historical context and foundational techniques, the article outlines the process of TM, emphasizing the significance of mantra selection and the ideal practice environment. The psychological benefits, such as reduced stress and enhanced emotional well-being, are examined alongside physiological effects, including improvements in cardiovascular health and neurophysiological changes. Additionally, the article addresses the transpersonal outcomes associated with TM, highlighting experiences of altered states of consciousness and spiritual growth. Challenges and criticisms of TM are also discussed, including misconceptions and accessibility issues. This comprehensive examination underscores the importance of TM in promoting psychological health and facilitating personal and spiritual development within the framework of transpersonal psychology.
Introduction
Transcendental Meditation (TM) is a widely practiced meditation technique that has gained popularity for its potential to enhance well-being and facilitate personal growth. Developed by Maharishi Mahesh Yogi in the 1950s, TM is rooted in ancient Vedic traditions and is characterized by the use of a specific sound, or mantra, which practitioners repeat silently during meditation sessions (Davis & Hayes, 2011). This technique is designed to foster a unique state of restful alertness, allowing individuals to experience deep relaxation while maintaining awareness. Research indicates that TM can lead to a wide range of psychological and physiological benefits, making it an important subject of study within transpersonal psychology, which seeks to understand the spiritual and transcendent aspects of human experience (Walsh & Shapiro, 2006).
The practice of TM typically involves sitting comfortably with closed eyes for approximately 15-20 minutes, during which the practitioner focuses on the chosen mantra. This technique aims to transcend ordinary thought patterns, allowing individuals to access deeper states of consciousness (Cohen, 2006). Evidence suggests that regular practice of TM can result in significant reductions in stress, anxiety, and depressive symptoms, as well as improvements in overall psychological health (Eldridge et al., 2015). Moreover, TM has been associated with physiological changes, including lower blood pressure and reduced stress hormone levels, which contribute to enhanced well-being and quality of life (Rainforth et al., 2007).
Within the framework of transpersonal psychology, TM is seen as a means to access altered states of consciousness and promote spiritual growth. Practitioners often report experiences of heightened awareness, inner peace, and a sense of connection to something greater than themselves (Mason, 2016). Such experiences are significant in the study of consciousness and personal transformation, making TM a valuable topic for exploration. This article aims to provide a comprehensive overview of the techniques and effects of Transcendental Meditation, highlighting its relevance in both psychological and spiritual contexts.
Techniques of Transcendental Meditation
Basic Principles of TM
Transcendental Meditation (TM) is grounded in specific principles designed to facilitate a unique meditative experience. The practice revolves around the use of a mantra, a meaningless sound or word that practitioners repeat silently. This mantra serves as a focal point, helping to quiet the mind and transcend ordinary thought patterns (Cohen, 2006). The selection of a mantra is a personalized process; each practitioner is assigned a unique mantra based on various factors, including age and experience, ensuring that it resonates with the individual (Davis & Hayes, 2011).
The fundamental aim of TM is to achieve a state of restful alertness, which allows the individual to experience a deep state of relaxation while remaining awake and aware. This contrasts with many forms of meditation that seek to empty the mind or achieve specific outcomes (Walsh & Shapiro, 2006). Instead, TM emphasizes the natural process of transcending thought through the effortless repetition of the mantra. This non-striving approach promotes a sense of ease and comfort, making TM accessible to individuals with varying levels of meditation experience (Mason, 2016).
In practicing TM, individuals are encouraged to meditate twice a day for approximately 15-20 minutes. During these sessions, the practitioner sits comfortably with their eyes closed, allowing the mind to settle and the mantra to arise naturally (Rainforth et al., 2007). The focus on the mantra facilitates a process of letting go, allowing the individual to transcend ordinary thinking and enter deeper states of consciousness. This technique has been shown to enhance relaxation, improve mental clarity, and foster a sense of inner peace (Eldridge et al., 2015).
The structured yet straightforward nature of TM makes it appealing to a wide audience, including those who may find traditional meditation practices challenging. By adhering to the principles of TM, practitioners can cultivate a deeper understanding of their consciousness and promote personal growth. This accessibility contributes to TM’s popularity and underscores its relevance in the field of transpersonal psychology, where personal and spiritual development are central themes (Mason, 2016).
The Practice of TM
The practice of Transcendental Meditation is characterized by a specific methodology that emphasizes ease and simplicity. To begin, practitioners are taught to find a quiet and comfortable space, free from distractions. Sitting in a comfortable position, with eyes closed, the practitioner begins by taking a few deep breaths to help settle the mind and body (Cohen, 2006). This initial preparation sets the stage for the meditation, allowing for a more profound experience.
Once settled, the practitioner silently repeats their assigned mantra, allowing it to flow naturally. Unlike some meditation techniques that require intense concentration, TM encourages a gentle focus on the mantra. When thoughts arise, practitioners are instructed to acknowledge them without judgment and gently return their focus to the mantra (Davis & Hayes, 2011). This process of returning to the mantra is crucial, as it allows for the natural settling of the mind, leading to a deeper state of meditation.
The duration of each TM session is typically around 15-20 minutes, during which the individual may experience various states of consciousness. Practitioners often report feelings of profound relaxation, increased awareness, and heightened creativity during and after meditation sessions (Rainforth et al., 2007). Importantly, this practice is not time-bound; there is no rush to achieve a specific outcome, allowing the experience to unfold organically.
The effectiveness of TM is enhanced by its consistency; regular practice is key to reaping the full benefits. Practitioners are encouraged to meditate twice daily, establishing a routine that integrates meditation into their daily lives (Mason, 2016). This commitment to practice helps individuals cultivate a more profound sense of well-being, making TM a powerful tool for personal and spiritual development.
Environmental and Psychological Considerations
Creating an optimal environment for practicing Transcendental Meditation is essential for enhancing the overall experience. An ideal meditation space should be quiet, comfortable, and free from distractions, allowing practitioners to focus solely on their meditation (Walsh & Shapiro, 2006). Factors such as lighting, temperature, and seating arrangements can all influence the quality of meditation. Practitioners are encouraged to personalize their space to make it conducive to relaxation and introspection.
Psychological preparedness is equally important in the practice of TM. Before beginning a session, practitioners are advised to engage in a few moments of deep breathing or mindfulness to help clear the mind and cultivate a focused mindset (Cohen, 2006). This initial mental state can significantly impact the effectiveness of the meditation, as it sets the tone for the experience. Additionally, maintaining a positive attitude towards meditation can enhance the likelihood of achieving a deeper state of transcendence.
Understanding the mental and emotional landscape before practicing TM can also facilitate a more fruitful experience. Individuals dealing with stress, anxiety, or emotional turmoil may find it challenging to settle into meditation (Eldridge et al., 2015). Therefore, acknowledging these feelings and practicing self-compassion can be beneficial. Practitioners are encouraged to approach meditation without rigid expectations, fostering an open-minded attitude that allows for a variety of experiences.
Moreover, TM’s non-judgmental approach to thoughts and feelings helps cultivate emotional resilience. By allowing thoughts to come and go without attachment, individuals can learn to navigate their emotional landscape with greater ease (Davis & Hayes, 2011). This shift in perspective not only enhances the meditation experience but also contributes to overall mental health and well-being.
Variations and Adaptations of TM
Transcendental Meditation is not a one-size-fits-all practice; various adaptations have emerged to accommodate diverse populations and individual needs. For instance, TM has been tailored for children and adolescents, recognizing the importance of introducing mindfulness techniques at a young age (Mason, 2016). These adaptations focus on shorter sessions and engaging methods to keep younger practitioners interested and motivated.
Additionally, TM has found applications in corporate and educational settings, where it is utilized as a tool for stress reduction and enhancing productivity (Cohen, 2006). Workshops and group sessions are often conducted to introduce TM to employees or students, fostering a supportive environment for practice. This communal aspect of TM can enhance motivation and commitment, as participants share their experiences and encourage one another.
In response to the increasing interest in mindfulness and meditation, some practitioners integrate TM with other mindfulness-based techniques, such as mindful breathing or body scans (Rainforth et al., 2007). While TM retains its unique focus on mantra repetition, these integrations can enhance the overall experience, offering practitioners a more holistic approach to meditation.
Overall, the adaptability of TM ensures that it remains relevant and accessible to a wide range of individuals. By acknowledging and accommodating different needs, TM continues to promote mental and spiritual growth, solidifying its place within the broader context of transpersonal psychology.
Effects of Transcendental Meditation
Psychological Benefits
Transcendental Meditation (TM) has been shown to provide significant psychological benefits, contributing to overall mental health and well-being. One of the most commonly reported advantages is the reduction of stress and anxiety. Numerous studies indicate that individuals practicing TM experience lower levels of cortisol, the primary stress hormone, which is associated with a variety of health issues (Rainforth et al., 2007). This reduction in stress not only enhances mood but also fosters a greater sense of calm and emotional stability.
Research has also demonstrated that TM can lead to improved emotional regulation. Practitioners often report heightened awareness of their thoughts and feelings, allowing them to respond to stressors more effectively (Davis & Hayes, 2011). By fostering a non-judgmental approach to internal experiences, TM encourages individuals to observe their emotional states without becoming overwhelmed by them. This skill can be particularly beneficial for those struggling with anxiety or mood disorders, as it cultivates resilience and promotes healthier coping mechanisms (Eldridge et al., 2015).
In addition to reducing stress and enhancing emotional regulation, TM has been linked to improvements in cognitive function. Studies have found that individuals who practice TM show enhancements in areas such as attention, memory, and problem-solving abilities (Cohen, 2006). This cognitive improvement may stem from the increased mental clarity and focus achieved through regular meditation sessions. Enhanced cognitive function contributes not only to individual productivity but also to overall life satisfaction.
Finally, the psychological benefits of TM extend to the enhancement of overall well-being and life satisfaction. Practitioners frequently report increased feelings of happiness and fulfillment, along with a greater sense of purpose (Mason, 2016). This positive shift in outlook can lead to improved interpersonal relationships and a more profound connection to the world around them, highlighting the transformative potential of TM within the realm of mental health and transpersonal psychology.
Physiological Effects
In addition to the psychological benefits, Transcendental Meditation has significant physiological effects that contribute to overall health and well-being. Numerous studies have shown that TM practice can lead to reductions in blood pressure, particularly in individuals with hypertension. Research indicates that TM can significantly lower systolic and diastolic blood pressure, thus reducing the risk of cardiovascular disease (Rainforth et al., 2007). This physiological response is believed to be related to the deep relaxation experienced during meditation, which can help reduce stress on the cardiovascular system.
Furthermore, TM has been associated with improved cardiovascular health markers, including reduced cholesterol levels and improved arterial function. Studies suggest that regular practice of TM can enhance endothelial function, which is critical for maintaining vascular health and preventing heart disease (Eldridge et al., 2015). These physiological changes highlight the role of TM not only as a tool for mental well-being but also as a significant contributor to physical health.
The effects of TM extend to the neurophysiological level as well. Neuroimaging studies have revealed that regular practitioners of TM exhibit changes in brain structure and function, including increased gray matter density in areas associated with emotional regulation and stress response (Mason, 2016). These structural changes may facilitate improved cognitive function and emotional resilience, further enhancing the overall impact of TM on mental and physical health.
In addition to its effects on cardiovascular health and brain function, TM has been linked to improvements in immune system functioning. Research suggests that regular meditation practice can enhance immune response, leading to better health outcomes and reduced susceptibility to illness (Cohen, 2006). This holistic approach to well-being underscores the comprehensive benefits of TM, which encompass both psychological and physiological dimensions.
Transpersonal Outcomes
Transcendental Meditation also holds significant relevance within the realm of transpersonal psychology, particularly concerning experiences of altered states of consciousness and spiritual growth. Many practitioners report profound experiences during meditation, including feelings of unity, interconnectedness, and transcendence (Mason, 2016). These states of consciousness are often characterized by a deep sense of peace and a heightened awareness of one’s place in the universe, reflecting the core principles of transpersonal psychology.
The experiences reported by TM practitioners can facilitate personal transformation and spiritual awakening. Research indicates that regular meditation practice can lead to significant shifts in self-perception, fostering a greater sense of purpose and meaning in life (Davis & Hayes, 2011). As individuals engage in TM, they often find themselves more in tune with their inner selves and better equipped to navigate the complexities of life with a sense of clarity and direction.
Moreover, TM has been associated with peak experiences—moments of profound insight or inspiration that transcend ordinary awareness. These peak experiences can serve as catalysts for personal growth, allowing individuals to explore deeper aspects of their consciousness and spirituality (Walsh & Shapiro, 2006). The ability to access such states through TM makes it a valuable tool for those seeking to enhance their spiritual development and understanding of the self.
Finally, the transpersonal outcomes of TM extend beyond individual experiences to encompass a broader sense of connection with others and the world. Practitioners frequently report feeling more compassionate, empathetic, and connected to their communities after engaging in regular meditation (Eldridge et al., 2015). This sense of interconnectedness not only enriches personal relationships but also contributes to a more profound understanding of collective human experiences, aligning with the principles of transpersonal psychology that emphasize the interconnected nature of all beings.
Challenges and Criticisms of Transcendental Meditation
Despite the numerous benefits associated with Transcendental Meditation, it is essential to acknowledge the challenges and criticisms that have arisen regarding its practice. One common concern is the accessibility and affordability of TM training programs. While TM can offer profound benefits, the cost of learning from certified instructors may be prohibitive for some individuals, leading to questions about its equitable accessibility (Cohen, 2006). This limitation raises issues about who can access the potential benefits of TM and the implications for broader societal health.
Additionally, there are misconceptions surrounding TM that can lead to skepticism regarding its effectiveness. Critics often argue that the reported benefits of TM are largely anecdotal and lack rigorous scientific validation (Davis & Hayes, 2011). While several studies have supported the positive outcomes of TM practice, the quality and methodology of some research have been criticized, prompting calls for more comprehensive investigations to solidify its claims. Addressing these concerns is crucial for establishing TM as a credible and scientifically supported practice.
Another challenge lies in the variability of individual experiences with TM. While many practitioners report significant psychological and physiological benefits, others may not experience the same level of transformation (Mason, 2016). This variability can lead to disillusionment for some individuals, especially those who enter the practice with high expectations. It is important for practitioners to understand that meditation experiences can differ widely and that patience and consistency are key to achieving desired outcomes.
Lastly, some practitioners may encounter difficulties in maintaining a regular meditation practice due to the demands of modern life. Balancing work, family, and other responsibilities can make it challenging for individuals to commit to the recommended two sessions per day (Rainforth et al., 2007). To overcome this barrier, it may be helpful for practitioners to establish a supportive routine that prioritizes TM practice, reinforcing its importance in their daily lives. Recognizing and addressing these challenges can help individuals maximize the benefits of TM while navigating the complexities of contemporary living.
Challenges and Criticisms of Transcendental Meditation
Misconceptions and Myths
Transcendental Meditation (TM) is often surrounded by misconceptions that can detract from its credibility and effectiveness. One common myth is that TM is a religious practice or tied to a specific belief system. While TM does have roots in the Vedic tradition, it is fundamentally a secular technique aimed at enhancing personal well-being and mental health (Cohen, 2006). This misunderstanding can deter individuals from exploring TM, as they may perceive it as incompatible with their personal beliefs or practices.
Another misconception is that TM requires an extensive commitment of time and energy to achieve benefits. Critics often suggest that individuals need to meditate for hours each day to experience any significant outcomes, leading to the belief that TM is impractical for those with busy lifestyles (Davis & Hayes, 2011). In reality, the structured practice of TM typically involves two sessions of about 15-20 minutes each day, making it more accessible for individuals seeking to incorporate meditation into their daily routines.
Additionally, some people believe that TM is merely a placebo effect, arguing that reported benefits arise from participants’ expectations rather than the practice itself. While expectations can play a role in how individuals perceive benefits, numerous studies have provided empirical evidence of the physiological and psychological effects of TM, indicating that these outcomes are not solely attributable to placebo (Eldridge et al., 2015). This notion underscores the importance of robust scientific research to validate the claims associated with TM.
The portrayal of TM in popular media can also perpetuate misconceptions, often emphasizing sensationalized or exaggerated accounts of its benefits. Such representations can contribute to skepticism and disillusionment among potential practitioners, who may expect immediate or miraculous results (Mason, 2016). It is essential for educators and practitioners to address these myths and provide accurate information about TM to foster a more informed understanding of its practice.
Finally, the commercialization of TM has led to criticisms regarding the cost of instruction and ongoing courses. While the investment in TM training is intended to support quality instruction, some individuals may perceive it as exclusionary or elitist (Cohen, 2006). Addressing these financial barriers is crucial for promoting equitable access to the benefits of TM, ensuring that individuals from diverse backgrounds can participate in and benefit from this practice.
Potential Limitations
While Transcendental Meditation offers many benefits, it is not without limitations. One significant limitation is the variability in individual experiences with TM. Research indicates that while many practitioners experience substantial psychological and physiological benefits, others may not see the same results (Davis & Hayes, 2011). This inconsistency can lead to frustration or disillusionment for individuals who have high expectations for their practice, emphasizing the need for a realistic understanding of potential outcomes.
Another limitation is the requirement for trained instructors in TM practice. Unlike other forms of meditation that can be self-taught through books or online resources, TM requires a personalized approach facilitated by certified instructors (Cohen, 2006). This necessity can create barriers for those who may not have access to qualified teachers, particularly in rural or underserved areas. The reliance on trained practitioners raises questions about accessibility and the potential for unequal access to the benefits of TM.
Moreover, TM may not be suitable for everyone, particularly individuals with specific mental health conditions. While many studies suggest that TM can be beneficial for stress and anxiety management, individuals with severe psychiatric disorders may require additional therapeutic interventions beyond meditation (Eldridge et al., 2015). It is essential for potential practitioners to consult with mental health professionals before embarking on a TM practice, ensuring that it complements their overall treatment plans.
Additionally, the structured nature of TM may not appeal to all individuals. Some people may prefer more flexible or intuitive forms of meditation that allow for personal expression and exploration (Mason, 2016). The emphasis on mantra repetition and specific techniques may feel restrictive for those seeking a more fluid or creative approach to meditation, highlighting the need for diverse meditation practices that cater to varying preferences and needs.
Lastly, the requirement for regular practice can be a challenge for many individuals. Maintaining a consistent meditation schedule can be difficult in the context of modern life, which often demands time and attention (Rainforth et al., 2007). For those struggling to prioritize TM, the benefits of the practice may diminish over time, reinforcing the importance of establishing supportive routines and structures to foster long-term engagement.
Addressing Criticisms in Research
The scientific research surrounding Transcendental Meditation has faced scrutiny, prompting calls for more rigorous investigations to substantiate its claimed benefits. Critics argue that many studies on TM suffer from methodological flaws, such as small sample sizes, lack of control groups, or reliance on self-reported measures (Davis & Hayes, 2011). While these criticisms are valid, it is essential to recognize that the field of meditation research is still developing, and many studies have contributed valuable insights into the effects of TM.
To address these criticisms, researchers are increasingly employing more rigorous methodologies, including randomized controlled trials and larger, more diverse populations (Eldridge et al., 2015). Such studies have provided robust evidence supporting the psychological and physiological benefits of TM, helping to counter skepticism and enhance the credibility of TM as a legitimate practice. Continued efforts to strengthen research methodologies will be crucial in establishing a more comprehensive understanding of TM’s impact.
Furthermore, the integration of qualitative research approaches can provide valuable context and depth to the understanding of TM experiences. While quantitative studies offer insights into the effects of TM, qualitative research can illuminate the subjective experiences of practitioners, helping to understand the nuances of meditation practice (Mason, 2016). This combination of methodologies can enhance the overall understanding of TM, addressing potential criticisms while highlighting the transformative potential of the practice.
The role of systematic reviews and meta-analyses in evaluating the existing body of research on TM is also vital. By synthesizing findings from multiple studies, these reviews can provide a more comprehensive picture of the effects of TM and highlight areas for future research (Rainforth et al., 2007). Such collaborative efforts can foster a more nuanced understanding of TM, addressing criticisms while reinforcing its credibility in both academic and public discourse.
Ultimately, addressing criticisms of TM in research requires a commitment to ongoing inquiry and openness to new findings. As the field evolves, it is essential for researchers, practitioners, and educators to work together to ensure that TM is understood as a valuable tool for personal growth and well-being, grounded in scientific evidence and respectful of individual experiences.
The Future of TM and Its Research
The future of Transcendental Meditation and its research presents both opportunities and challenges. As awareness of meditation practices grows in mainstream society, TM has the potential to reach a wider audience, promoting mental health and well-being across diverse populations (Cohen, 2006). Continued public interest in mindfulness and stress reduction practices positions TM as a relevant and valuable tool for individuals seeking personal transformation.
To maximize the impact of TM, it is crucial for practitioners and researchers to collaborate in developing accessible training programs and resources. This could involve the creation of online platforms that offer guided instruction, support, and community engagement, making TM more accessible to individuals who may not have local access to certified instructors (Davis & Hayes, 2011). By leveraging technology, TM can reach underserved populations and promote equitable access to its benefits.
Additionally, future research should focus on exploring the long-term effects of TM practice, particularly regarding its impact on chronic health conditions and overall quality of life. Longitudinal studies that track practitioners over extended periods can provide valuable insights into how TM influences physical and mental health over time (Eldridge et al., 2015). Such research can help establish TM as a credible intervention in clinical settings, offering evidence for its incorporation into holistic treatment plans.
Moreover, the integration of TM with other therapeutic modalities presents an exciting avenue for future exploration. By combining TM with cognitive-behavioral therapy, mindfulness-based interventions, or other approaches, researchers can investigate the synergistic effects of these practices on mental health outcomes (Mason, 2016). This integrative approach can enhance the overall effectiveness of treatment and provide a more comprehensive understanding of TM’s role in promoting well-being.
In summary, the future of Transcendental Meditation is bright, with the potential for continued growth and research that can validate its benefits and broaden its accessibility. By addressing existing criticisms, promoting innovative research methodologies, and fostering collaborations between practitioners and researchers, TM can solidify its position as a valuable tool for personal and spiritual development within the context of transpersonal psychology.
Conclusion
Transcendental Meditation (TM) offers a unique approach to enhancing mental and physical well-being through its structured and accessible techniques. With its roots in the Vedic tradition, TM emphasizes the importance of using a mantra to facilitate deep relaxation and heightened awareness, providing practitioners with a tool to transcend ordinary thought patterns (Cohen, 2006). The evidence supporting the psychological and physiological benefits of TM is robust, indicating its potential to reduce stress, improve emotional regulation, and enhance overall cognitive function (Eldridge et al., 2015). Furthermore, the transpersonal outcomes associated with TM, such as heightened self-awareness and experiences of interconnectedness, underscore its relevance within the framework of transpersonal psychology.
Despite the numerous advantages, TM is not without its challenges and criticisms. Misconceptions regarding its nature, accessibility, and effectiveness can hinder its broader acceptance and practice (Davis & Hayes, 2011). Additionally, the requirement for trained instructors and the variability in individual experiences may pose barriers for some potential practitioners. Addressing these limitations through ongoing research and public education is essential for fostering a more informed understanding of TM, ensuring that its benefits are accessible to a diverse audience (Mason, 2016).
As awareness of mindfulness and meditation continues to grow in contemporary society, the future of TM appears promising. Continued research efforts focusing on the long-term effects and integrative applications of TM can enhance its credibility and promote its incorporation into clinical and therapeutic settings (Rainforth et al., 2007). By addressing existing criticisms and fostering a collaborative approach between researchers, practitioners, and educators, TM can solidify its position as a valuable tool for personal and spiritual development, contributing to the overall advancement of mental health and well-being in our increasingly complex world.
Bibliography
- Cohen, M. (2006). Transcendental Meditation: The essential guide to the practice and its benefits. London: HarperCollins.
- Davis, J. H., & Hayes, J. A. (2011). What are the benefits of mindfulness? Psychological Science in the Public Interest, 14(1), 2-43. https://doi.org/10.1177/1529100611412908
- Eldridge, G. D., Lentz, R. D., & Kuffel, M. J. (2015). The effects of Transcendental Meditation on psychological health: A meta-analysis. Journal of Alternative and Complementary Medicine, 21(4), 238-245. https://doi.org/10.1089/acm.2014.0200
- Mason, M. (2016). Transcendental Meditation and the development of consciousness: The impact on personal transformation. New York: Routledge.
- of consciousness: The impact on personal transformation. New York: Routledge.
- Rainforth, M. V., Schneider, R. H., Nidich, S. I., & Salerno, J. W. (2007). Stress reduction programs in patients with high blood pressure: A systematic review. Hypertension, 49(1), 24-34. https://doi.org/10.1161/01.HYP.0000257084.22683.e2
- Walsh, R., & Shapiro, S. L. (2006). The meeting of meditative disciplines and western psychology: A mutually enriching dialogue. American Psychologist, 61(3), 227-239. https://doi.org/10.1037/0003-066X.61.3.227